UnexplainedUnexplained
The Eau Gallie River Lights
For over a decade, residents along the Eau Gallie River reported mysterious lights hovering over the water at night, with no explanation ever confirmed.
★ BREVARD COUNTY COLD FILES ★
UNSOLVEDMYSTERIES
The cases that still haunt the 321
COLD CASES ★ UNSOLVED ★ BREVARD MYSTERIES ★ WHO KNOWS THE TRUTH ★ COLD CASES ★ UNSOLVED ★ BREVARD MYSTERIES ★ WHO KNOWS THE TRUTH ★ COLD CASES ★ UNSOLVED ★ BREVARD MYSTERIES ★ WHO KNOWS THE TRUTH ★ COLD CASES ★ UNSOLVED ★ BREVARD MYSTERIES ★ WHO KNOWS THE TRUTH ★ COLD CASES ★ UNSOLVED ★ BREVARD MYSTERIES ★ WHO KNOWS THE TRUTH ★ COLD CASES ★ UNSOLVED ★ BREVARD MYSTERIES ★ WHO KNOWS THE TRUTH ★ COLD CASES ★ UNSOLVED ★ BREVARD MYSTERIES ★ WHO KNOWS THE TRUTH ★ COLD CASES ★ UNSOLVED ★ BREVARD MYSTERIES ★ WHO KNOWS THE TRUTH ★
Some cases listed here involve real people and real events. We present them with respect and in the interest of keeping awareness alive. If you have any information about an active case, please contact the Brevard County Sheriff's Office or Crimeline at 1-800-423-TIPS.
Featured CaseActive Missing Person
The Disappearance of Tammy Lynn Leppert
In the summer of 1983, 18-year-old Tammy Lynn Leppert — a pageant queen, model, and aspiring actress from Rockledge — vanished after being dropped off in Cocoa Beach. In the weeks before, she exhibited extreme fear and paranoia, claiming someone was trying to kill her. Over four decades later, her disappearance remains one of Brevard County's most haunting unsolved mysteries.
Read Full Story
Featured CaseActive Missing Person
Vanished Without a Trace: Jeannine Carfi-Arnold Erwin
On the evening of March 12, 2006, Jeannine Carfi-Arnold Erwin — a 33-year-old mother of four from Melbourne's Sherwood Park neighborhood — vanished from her home on Plompton Drive. Her purse, cellphone, and all personal belongings were left behind. She did not have a car. Her husband delayed reporting her missing for nearly a week, and phone records later contradicted his account of the night. Nearly twenty years later, no trace of Jeannine has ever been found.
Read Full Story
Featured CaseActive Missing Person
The Disappearance of Brandy Hall
On the night of August 17, 2006, volunteer firefighter and mother of two Brandy Hall left the Malabar Fire Department and was never seen again. Her truck was found submerged in a Palm Bay pond with blood inside, but Brandy was not there. Nearly twenty years later, new leads have brought fresh momentum — but the truth remains buried.
Read Full Story
UnsolvedUnsolved
The Barefoot Mailman of South Brevard
A Palm Bay postal carrier discovered a series of cryptic handwritten letters in mailboxes along his route — none with return addresses, all containing the same mysterious message.
UnexplainedUnexplained
The Pineda Causeway Incident
Multiple motorists reported their car radios switching to the same unknown frequency while crossing the Pineda Causeway, broadcasting what sounded like decades-old audio.
UnexplainedHistorically Disputed
Who Built the Concrete Ships?
Remnants of mysterious concrete vessels visible in the Indian River have puzzled locals for generations, with competing theories about their origin.
Have Information?
If you have information about any unsolved case in Brevard County, your tip could make a difference. All tips can be submitted anonymously.